Yachtsman Steakhouse Review

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Yachtsman Steakhouse is the real “T-Rex Cafe” in Walt Disney World. Except instead of being themed to dinosaurs, Yachtsman Steakhouse is a restaurant for dinosaurs. Well, at least the carnivorous ones. The place should have been named “Disney’s Awesome Salute to Carnivores Restaurant (of Excellence).” Unfortunately, Disney went with the more conventional “Yachtsman Steakhouse.”

Yachtsman Steakhouse is a signature restaurant at Disney’s Yacht Club Resort. Although we both love steak, it had taken us a while to visit Yachtsman Steakhouse because we always kept putting it off in favor of other favorites. We finally decided to visit Yachtsman Steakhouse when on the Deluxe Disney Dining Plan and trying to get the most bang for our buck . The restaurant is themed to a New England steakhouse, with masculine woods and some almost-kitschy coastal accents. While the restaurant is fairly well-lit, the rich woods and nice-looking rooms give it a look of understated elegance.

There are a few other items on the menu , but Yachtsman Steakhouse’s clear specialty is steak (hence the name…although wouldn’t its specialty be a touch more clear if they went with my proposed name?). As a signature restaurant participating in the Disney Dining Plan , Yachtsman Steakhouse is a 2-credit table service restaurant, and one of the restaurants at Walt Disney World that now requires a $10 per person deposit to secure reservations. It also accepts the Tables in Wonderland card for a 20% discount .

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

I’ve already touched upon the decor and its kitsch, but it’s probably worth discussing a bit more (and at the front of the review, to get all negatives out of the way first). Yachtsman Steakhouse looks nice with its masculine woods and understated dining room, and the highlight is when you first walk in and see a butcher room with meats aging and, when we were there, a butcher in there actually making his cuts!

However, there are also a few random accents that make the restaurant feel as if it’s stuck in the mid-1990s. I know plenty of New England restaurants have this same “look” to them, but I think Disney could convey the theme of the restaurant without the dated paintings and wallpaper. These are just little things, and it’s difficult to point to any one element of the design that made it feel dated, but I think all of these little things are more noticeable because the dining rooms are otherwise very understated.

That said, we ate there prior to the restaurant’s August and September 2012 refurbishment, and I have not yet heard what, if anything, changed with the look of the restaurant. Hopefully this decor was freshened up during the refurbishment, and if so, Yachtsman Steakhouse would be flawless to us. (Has anyone been there since September 14, 2012? How did it look?)

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Our waiter for our meal at Yachtsman Steakhouse was Ricardo, and he was flat out awesome. He was incredibly fun, yet formal and knowledgeable of the menu. How he managed to strike this balance was beyond me, but he was basically the perfect Disney server–easily one of the best we’ve ever had at Walt Disney World or Disneyland. A bit of whimsy combined with knowledge and appropriate demeanor for a nicer restaurant.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Before diving into the substance of our meal, I should preface this review with some basic information about my food preferences. On a scale of “Vegan to Velociraptor” in terms of carnivorousness, I’m approximately “Tyrannosaurus Rex,” which is a step beyond Velociraptor (see how happy I am in the photo above? I’m like a kid in a candy store when I’m at a steakhouse!). So I’m off the chart as far as my enjoyment of meat goes. I actually view vegetables as unnecessary filler that gets in the way of meat. Except potatoes, but I’ve been told countless times those are not vegetables, so I guess they get a pass. Obviously there’s some hyperbole here, but my point is that if you’re a vegan or vegetarian, it’s likely that you and I will not share similar views of Yachtsman Steakhouse.

In short, Yachtsman Steakhouse brings the A-game for steak-lovers. The meal started out with a bread basket, the highlight of which is the delicious onion bread. That onion bread plus the roasted garlic and butter is a deadly combination (for anyone you talk to later in the night). It’s also a highly, highly delicious combination. Normally we don’t like to overdo it on bread, but when Ricardo asked if we’d like another basket of bread, the answer was an unequivocal “YES!”

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

For appetizers, we both ordered the same fried crab appetizer, and it was incredible. Not only was the crab perfectly breaded and prepared, but the tomatoes and other garnishes were excellent!

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Now, on to the glorious entrees! Sarah had the Surf ‘n’ Turf (butter-poached Maine Lobster and Prime Strip Steak), and I had the 24 oz Porterhouse.

My Porterhouse was amazing. Flavorful, perfectly marbled, and with the perfect amount of seasoning. The roasted garlic butter added a great flavor to the steak, but it wasn’t doused in this butter so heavily that it masked the steak’s own natural flavor. Those who like incredibly lean cuts might not be as big of fans of this Porterhouse (or any Porterhouse, for that matter), but I like a bit of fat for flavor. If Yachtsman Steakhouse sold post cards, I would have bought one, because that steak was something to write home about!

At $46 it was pricey even by Disney standards, but it was 24 ounces and amazing. Given that, I don’t think it was out of line compared to other steak on property, especially for the size. It was certainly better than the $66 entree I had the day before at Narcoossee’s! I would not recommend visiting Yachtsman Steakhouse with an eye towards “dining on a dime,” but the Porterhouse was definitely large enough for two people to split if you want to go that route.

Usually I try to only post one or two photos of each entree we have in these reviews, but I’m having a tough time cutting anything here, so I’ll just present this glorious tribute to the Porterhouse:

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Check out our Disney Dining Index Page — Links to all of our restaurant reviews and other resources!

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

I may not look all that happy in this photo, but really, I’m just in the zone. Eating a steak this excellent requires dedication and concentration. No time for posed photos.

Truly the best overall steak I’ve had on Disney property. The filet mignon at Napa Rose comes close , and it’s difficult to compare two radically different cuts of meat, but I’m going to give the edge to Yachtsman Steakhouse.

As for Sarah’s meal, Sarah reported that her lobster was better than the lobster she had at Narcoossee’s . If you recall, she had a whole Maine Lobster at Narcoossee’s, so this is assessment is impressive since usually the lobster on a combo lobster/filet dish is inferior to the lobster on a dedicated “whole Maine lobster” dish. She described the lobster as tender, flavorful, and perfectly cooked, and similarly really liked the steak. I tried some of her strip steak, and while it didn’t compare to my Porterhouse, it was very excellent. Tender and juicy, especially for a strip steak.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

After dinner, Sarah ordered a cup of cappuccino. I’m not really sure which one, and I know almost nothing about coffee, so I can’t accurately assess it, but to my uninformed palate, it tasted delicious!

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

For dessert, I had the Peanut Butter and Pretzel Gianduja Cake, with salted caramel gelato and liquid ganache. This dessert was the bomb(dotcom) ! Even though it was really rich, I didn’t mind at all, because I love peanut butter and it wasn’t too large (who am I kidding, it could have been 10 times this size and I would’ve eaten it all!). The mix of flavors and textures in the cake were excellent, and I had never had caramel gelato before this–it was also quite good. At $11, it was fairly expensive for a relatively small dessert, but it tasted excellent. I probably wouldn’t have paid that much for it out of pocket, but as a Disney Dining Plan dessert, it’s a great pick.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Sarah had the Lemon Pudding Cake, which she said was pretty good. She said it was incredibly moist, and that the blueberry shake that accompanied it was also excellent. I’m not quite sure about the war paint in the middle of her plate there, but I guess that’s how New England steakhouses present their desserts. Chowder-heads! 😉

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

All in all, Yachtsman Steakhouse was amazing. Our meal was, essentially, a tribute to America. That meal at Yachtsman Steakhouse cemented the restaurant as one of our top Walt Disney World restaurants. Our meal surpassed Bistro de Paris by a tad to claim the #2 overall slot for best restaurants at Walt Disney World ( behind only Victoria & Albert’s ). Although there are some dated elements in the decor, that was hardly enough to ding Yachtsman Steakhouse’s score.

The next time we eat at Yachtsman Steakhouse, we definitely won’t use the Disney Dining Plan, and will skip appetizers and desserts in favor of the many steakhouse-style sides that can be ordered to accompany the steaks. We saw a few of these pass our table, and they looked excellent. Our appetizers and desserts were good, but they were expensive (especially the desserts), and I’d rather focus on steakhouse strengths when at a steakhouse. It’ll be difficult, but I’ll probably also order the Beef Wellington next time instead of the Porterhouse. The Porterhouse was absolutely amazing, but I suspect just about any cut of meat will be amazing at Yachtsman. We highly recommend Yachtsman Steakhouse to anyone who enjoys a good steak.

Are you a fan of Yachtsman Steakhouse? Share your thoughts, especially any experiences with their other (glorious?) cuts of meat, in the comments!

Overall Score: 10/10

' src=

Written by Tom Bricker

' src=

Another request for an update now that it has re-opened again. Thanks!

' src=

Any plans to do an updated review here soon? It says you haven’t been here since 2012 yet you said it was amazing and gave it a 10/10. Hoping to see some updated thoughts on this steakhouse as well as Le Cellier as we’re trying to decided between the two for our upcoming June 2020 trip. Thanks!

' src=

I agree!! The menu has had soooo many changes since then. Would love an updated review.

' src=

Just eaten here for the third time and was a total disaster. Our waiter knew little about the menu or drinks then forgot 2 of the drinks we ordered one was Diet Coke so not too hard to remember The steaks arrived my wife said medium fillet was cold on the outside and centre one sons steak was fine he asked for fries not mash and no sauce which arrived ok My other son and I shared a porterhouse which was excellent then the problems started alll the side dishes wee cold and looked as if they were preprepared and left on one side . We complained to which we were told they would be replaced immediately Then mash and sauce arrived for our sons steak which was ordered without and arrived perfectly After we had nearly finished the porterhouse my wife’s steak arrived it was the original steak reheated as were all the side dishes which were then TrueType inedible. The manager apologised on many occasions and sent extra desserts Monod which I could eat as I am diabetic which I told the waiter originally The y did reduce the credits taken from the dining plan plan but I would have sooner had a good meal and used all the credits WE will not be revisiting soon

' src=

Hi- just curious why you wouldn’t use the Dining plan for this restaurant? This is our first time at DW, so i’m confused. Thank you

' src=

I assume he means because the dining plan specifies that you get appetizer, entree, and dessert as opposed to steak with added sides of your choice. With the dining plan, you have less control over how you spend your money at each meal.

' src=

It is by far my favorite restaurant at DW & I’ve eaten at most. Their bone marrow w/the ribeye is out of this world! I think they lace it w/crack bc I dream of this bone marrow!

' src=

We went here in 2015, this review is spot on with our experience. We are going back in 2017 and agree that we aren’t doing the dining plan. We also thought the steakhouse sides looked really good. We plan to share the porterhouse and get a few different sides to share. This is one of our must have ADRs for this next trip.

' src=

Don’t worry about the decor…it’s elegant and appropriate as you would expect. The food is exceptional! What a treat! Don’t overlook what is certainly one of Disney’s best………and one of the most outstandiing steakhouses ANYWHERE! Bravo!

' src=

I’ll be there for dinner on January 06, 2015. Thanks for the amazing review!

' src=

My hubby and I have an ADR here for the beginning of October. We are from New England so I’ve been hesitant to keep the reservation. My indecisive nature makes me want to try something new and exciting yet knows we’d love the Yachtsman. Any current thoughts on a signature restaurant for two? I’m dying to go to V&A but it’s just not in the budget this trip. Thanks!! Love your blog!

California Grill would be very nice!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Notify me of follow-up comments by email.

Notify me of new posts by email.

Ziggy Knows Disney

Home » Walt Disney World

Yachtsman Steakhouse Full Review

By Author Ziggy Oskwarek

Posted on Last updated: July 24, 2019

Yachtsman Steakhouse offers a variety of amazing food including some great seafood dishes, but they really specialize in…you guessed it… Red Meat , big juicy slabs of it!  In fact many put it in the conversation for best steak on property .  Being a Signature Restaurant means you won’t find a cheap meal here, but I’ve always found the quality to equal the price.  Also a certain “business casual” dress code is required so I wouldn’t come in a tank top and flip-flops. 😉

Yachtsman’s often gets a bit overlooked because of having to travel to the Yacht Club to eat there and is also viewed as being a bit “stuffy.”  But is that the case?  How does it compare with other Steak heavyweights such as Le Cellier, Shula’s and Jiko?

It’s been a few years so I wanted to do a Yachtsman Steakhouse Full Review.  I’m hoping that the good experiences we’ve had there in the past continue over this time….let’s find out!

Atmosphere:

To get to Yachtsman you’ll need to find your way to the Yacht Club Resort and make your way out to the back by the pool.  You can either take transportation to Epcot, Hollywood Studios or one of the other Epcot Resorts like the Boardwalk Resort, Beach Club or Swan and Dolphin.  To make it easy I would recommend doing either Epcot or Hollywood Studios the same day and then just either walk over to the Yacht Club Resort or take a Boat from the park.

If your coming from along the waterside of the resort then eventually you will run into the Back Entrance of the Yacht Club here:

The first thing you see when you walk in is the Meat Dry Aging Room where the butchers cut and prepare the steaks:

All the meat at the Yachtsman Steakhouse is cut in-house , you you know you’re getting a fresh quality steak, not something that’s been prepackaged.

Here’s the butcher going to work:

Look at that concentration, even with the camera in his face he didn’t look up once! 😉  Here’s a shot of the meat once he’s done cutting it:

Those are some good-looking steaks!!

If you look to the left into the Bar , you’ll start to get more of a feel for the decor.  Pine wood beams line the high ceiling, along with beautiful chandeliers:

A cool feature that’s a part of many upscale Disney restaurants is the Open-Kitchen:

Turn right and you’ll find the entrance to the Main Dining Hall:

Some people complain about the decor, they even find it stuffy or snobbish.  Personally I love the natural wood and soft tones you find throughout.  It’s supposed to be reminiscent of a sea-faring New England town, and that’s exactly what it delivers.  You’re not going to be blown away by the decor, like in a place like Moritmoto’s, but that’s ok because that’s not the focal point here, it’s the food.

The Main Dining Room is a large and open space.  Again more rich colors from the wood:

The lighting in here is excellent, especially when the sun is still out due to the large windows overlooking the Pool at Stormalong Bay.  That’s refreshing as at some steakhouses you practically have to bring a flashlight with you in order to see:

This room is gorgeous and has a great view of outside:

One of the tables in the main dining room:

This is the back dining room and probably the most intimate room at Yachtsman.  If you are looking for more quiet and privacy ask for here:

Or you can ask for one of the booths which are lovely:

Notice the gorgeous, clean light fixtures on the beams:

More typical sea-faring gear lines the walls like this Ship’s Wheel:

Some lovely paintings line the wall….of yachts of course:

Ok, we’re done looking around and we’re ready for the food!

As I already mentioned we came here for Steak, and lots of it, as that’s obviously the specialty of the house.  All the beef is high-quality and grain-fed which is cut and aged in-house and prepared on an oak-fired grill in the open kitchen.  That results in some of the tastiest steak anywhere in Walt Disney World.  If your wallet is feeling full and you want a dining experience you’ll never forget, then go for the 32 oz Porterhouse for Two or the 100% Japanese Wagyu Beef Strip Loin , they cost $119 and $125 respectively, but they will change your life!

Besides steak Yachtsman offers some other delicious options including F resh Seafood like Lobster, Salmon and Shrimp.   Expect to find typical Steakhouse appetizers and sides like Soups and Salads, Mushrooms, Creamed Spinach and Truffle Mac and Cheese.

Like many Disney restaurants, the menu tends to have some staples you can find year-round and then some options that are seasonal, so if you don’t find exactly the same things we had during our visit you can probably find something similar or even better when you go!

Look at these beauties…freshly cut and dry-aged.  It’s going to be so hard to choose….

That 21 Day Dry-aged Kansas City Strip looks amazing:

To start off our meal the right way we ordered a bottle of Robert Mondavi Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 , ok really 2 bottles but who’s counting?  The wine itself was excellent, balanced with a great structure and perfect for…steak!

They first brought us out our complimentary Bread Basket , this thing was amazing!

The first and yummiest bread was the Onion Brioche-style rolls that were out of this world!  They were pull-apart and had a light, airy texture inside that was incredible!  Look at that inside which I had slathered with butter:

Besides that there were also more traditional Sourdough Rolls that were also delicious:

The Butter Plate here was something special because not only did it have fresh butter with Coarse Sea Salt on top, but each plate also had a humongous Roasted Garlic Clove as well!  It was soooo good and my wife was soooo mad at me for eating it! 😉

Next we had a Caesar Salad ($12) with Romaine Lettuce, Parmigiano Reggiano, Coppa Secca and Focaccia Crouton.  Really is there any other type of salad to be had??

I’m a self-proclaimed expert on Caesar Salads and have eaten my share, but this thing was no joke!  It was a very big portion, even enough to share if you’re into that sort of thing.  The lettuce was really fresh and crisp and the Parmigiano was sliced super thin so you could really taste the sharpness of the flavors.  The dressing is what usually makes the Caesar salad and this one was awesome!!  It’s made in house and wasn’t goopy or sweet.

Next was the French Onion Soup ($12) which had a Sourdough Crouton and was covered in Gruyere Cheese:

This is perfection right here…

Stringy cheese makes me  :))))))))

Since it was nearly impossible to stand within 10 feet of us now after 2 courses a piece with either garlic or onion in them we decided to change it up. We went with the Lobster Bisque ($13) which is made with fresh Maine Lobster, Creme Fraiche, fine herbs and lemon:

We also tried the Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail ($19) which had a bit of Old Bay sprinkled on and came with lemon and a homemade cocktail sauce:

Get ready to get your carnivore on, because we’ve made our choices of Entrees and they are sent off to the kitchen to be cooked over that Oak-fired Grill:

First up was the 12oz New York Strip Steak ($49) with a Peppercorn Brandy Sauce and Potato Gratin:

You can see how nice that inside is:

Next was the 10oz Black Angus Filet Mignon ($54) with Mashed Potatoes and a Cabernet Wine Sauce:

Lastly was they one I was really anticipating, the 16oz Prime Rib Eye Steak ($54) covered in Blue Cheese Butter and served with a Brioche and Bone Marrow :

This thing is what dreams are made of!  The very first bite my wife said it’s the best steak she’s ever had:

Being rib-eye this thing was bursting with flavor, then covered in blue cheese butter it made everything so rich and juicy and brought it to even another level of amazingness.  It was a giant piece of meat that we ended up splitting between the two of us:

It was just the right tenderness and melted right in your mouth, especially in the middle.  Just overall awesome and one of the best steaks I’ve ever had!

It was accompanied with Bone Marrow and a Brioche .  Now maybe the idea of sucking marrow from a cow’s bone doesn’t exactly get your appetite going, but once you try it, it will!  The Italian name is Osso Buco and it’s a traditional dish from Milan and my wife goes absolutely crazy for it.  Being the expert she said it compared well to others she’s had before and was very succulent inside.

Lastly we got an order of Truffle Macaroni and Cheese ($12) , because obviously till that point we were really having a light meal!  It was made from Orecchiette Pasta (which means “little ears”), Reypenaer cheese and of course truffles:

There were also a bit of crisped stringy onions on top which added a nice texture.  The pasta was creamy and cheesy but you really have to like truffles to like this mac and cheese, the flavor is very strong.  My brother-in-law was crazy about it, he thought it was really unreal.  I personally thought the taste was a bit too strong, so it depends on tastes.

Of course even though at this point I was so stuffed that I needed to be rolled out of the restaurant, I wouldn’t leave you without at least a taste of Dessert.  I was the only one brave enough to confront it!  I got the Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake ($10) with Lemon Curd and Blueberry Crumble:

Lastly, one thing I haven’t touched on was the service.  The service here was some of the best I’ve ever had at any restaurant ANYWHERE .  We had 2 waiters assigned to our table all night as one was in training and the other was observing but helping him.  At first I thought we were in trouble because of having a waiter-in-training, but he blew us away!  He knew everything, literally everything about the menu and every recommendation he made to us turned out to be true.  I wish I remembered his name because I would highly recommend him to you.  This is what signature dining service should be like!

Overall we had a wonderful experience at the Yachtsman Steakhouse, it was even better than the last time we came.  The atmosphere won’t blow you away, but it’s warm, clean, it isn’t loud and is a nice place if you are looking for a quiet romantic meal.  The food was of excellent quality, the appetizers like Caesar Salad, French Onion Soup and the Lobster Bisque were all outstanding .  The Steaks themselves were unbelievable and do live up to the reputation as being one of the best 2 or 3 steakhouses on property.  Where exactly?  I’ll have to think about it and make a list soon, but Yachtsman is right up there.

I found the prices to be expensive, but in-line with other Disney Signature Restaurants.  If you are a carnivore like me then you will appreciate it and Yachtsman has to be on your list of must-try restaurants in Walt Disney World.  It’s a must do for sure if you are staying at one of the Epcot Resorts as it’s within walking distance from them, and it makes a great date-night location without the kids or for a special occasion.  Try it, you won’t be disappointed!

Yachtsman Steakhouse is a Dinner only restaurant and is open from roughly 5:00pm – 9:30pm Daily .  The Disney Dining Plan is also accepted, it is a 2 Disney Dining Credit Signature Restaurant.   Reservations can be made via the Disney World website or by calling (407) WDW-DINE .

Click here for the Yachtsman Steakhouse Menu.

I love to write Restaurant Reviews of Walt Disney World and I hope you found this one to be informative and helpful.  If you liked this review then please visit my Disney Dining Reviews Page where I have many other Restaurant Reviews . I’m happy sharing with you what I love doing best…eating! ?  I try to bring you the most thorough and unbiased reviews about the food and restaurants at Walt Disney World, so that as you are planning your vacation, you know the “can’t be missed” places, and where you shouldn’t waste your time.  Hope you enjoyed this one and will enjoy many others in the future!!

Your Thoughts:

I want to know what you think about my Yachtsman Steakhouse Full Review and if it’s in line with your experiences there.  What’s your favorite thing at Yachtsman Steakhouse?  Where does it rank among the list of Best Steaks in Walt Disney World?  Let us know in the comments section below!

If you enjoyed this article, as always I appreciate it if you’d share it with others via social media.  I work hard at making this website into a useful resource for you and your family to plan your visit to Walt Disney World, and I hope it can help you! Thanks 🙂

Ziggy Knows Disney close

My name is Ziggy and I love Disney, everything Disney! I grew up on Disney and it has and continues to be a huge part of my life. I started young when my parents took me to Disney World when I was 18 months old. Little did they know that would be the first of an uncountable number of trips we would take. I have so many amazing memories going to Disney with my family and friends and it has been interwoven into my DNA.

Thursday 10th of October 2019

I just had that same Caesar's Salad and a prime rib end-cut that was bigger than my head just two weeks ago. I've been going there since opening in 1990 and I couldn't have written a more detailed and accurate assessment of the Yachtsmen than you did. Love that place.

Yachtsman Steakhouse

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

YACHTSMAN STEAKHOUSE, Orlando - Updated 2024 Restaurant Reviews, Menu & Prices - Tripadvisor

Resorts Gal Logo with a red bow

A Favorable Review of Yachtsman Steakhouse

Yachtsman Steakhouse is the signature dining location at Disney’s Yacht Club Resort. Those looking to enjoy a meal with quality steaks during their Disney World vacation will want to consider this establishment.

In this review of Yachtsman Steakhouse, we’ll look at our latest dining experience along with a few thoughts for planning a meal here. Of course, given the title of this review, you probably already know our meal was delicious.

Looking back, I’m so glad this was the one signature dining location we chose over a week-long trip to Walt Disney World. Unfortunately, we had three fine dining experiences lined up for the week and had to cancel all of them.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Since I had spent most of the Fall months in Orlando, I returned home for the holidays. My son was finishing up his college semester, so I planned a short trip for us to return right before Christmas.

Initially, we had planned to do all of our favorite restaurants. However, I had recently dined at California Grill and wasn’t a fan of the prix fixe menu. Also, I wasn’t crazy about forking out another $200+ for the both of us since I recently reviewed the meal.

Yachtsman Steakhouse had been on my list to review for a while now, so I knew I wanted to include it in our trip. We tried to get Space 220, but that never came through. However, we planned a few others, like Hollywood Brown Derby , Frontera Cocina at Disney Springs , and Topolino’s Terrace.

I wish I could tell you I’ll have new reviews from all these restaurants. But unfortunately, I won’t. We had to cancel all of our dining reservations because my son got sick with asthma issues. He couldn’t go out for the majority of our trip. Unfortunately, he didn’t visit a park or dine out until the last three days. It was terrible having to rearrange everything.

Thankfully, we have been fortunate enough to visit the parks often. And as you know, I’m there nearly every time I turn around. So it wasn’t a huge disappointment for either of us. Most days, I’m grateful to halfway function.

Anyway, this experience left me on the My Disney Experience app canceling theme park reservations and dining reservations right and left. We had to take a trip to guest relations at Disney Springs to figure out his ticket since he could only use part of it.

The part we didn’t use was refunded on a Disney gift card, and he was allowed to pick out a few extra Christmas presents. So that worked out. And we enjoyed a meal at Chef Art Smith’s Homecomin’ while we were there, which turned out delightful. It is on our list of the best restaurants at Disney Springs .

Thankfully, when things settled down, I was able to secure a reservation at Yachtsman Steakhouse. Again. We ended up dining here on a Thursday evening instead of Sunday.

And after the meal, I was reminded why I only recommend one to two signature experiences for a week’s vacation. We were stuffed. And there’s no way I would have wanted to indulge in another elaborate meal the next day.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Yachtsman Steakhouse is located directly behind Stormalong Bay . A long walkway alongside the pool connects both Beach and Yacht Club. Yachtsman is the first restaurant you’ll encounter when you walk inside the Yacht Club from the pool area.

If you’re coming from the main lobby, you’ll want to walk down the hallway past Ale and Compass and then around the corner. You’ll run directly into the restaurant.

Next door to Yachtsman Steakhouse is Crew’s Cup Lounge. Crew’s Cup is a bit of a hole in the wall.

It’s one of the best places around the area to enjoy dinner when you don’t have a reservation. You can also order from Yachtsman’s menu since both locations share a kitchen.

Related: Crew’s Cup Lounge Review

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Upon arrival, we checked in and briefly waited to be seated.

A display shows all the butcher cuts served at the restaurant right inside the entrance. Regarding beef, you’ll have a choice of Filet Mignon, Roasted Prime Rib, New York Strip, Rib Eye Steak, or a Dry-Aged Porterhouse for two guests.

Here is a preview of the menu we received. Or you can view it here on Disney’s site.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

After being seated, our server took our drink order. Not long after, we received bread service. If you’ve ever heard of Yachtsman before this review, you’ve likely heard mention of their incredible onion rolls.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

These rolls are so soft, and they pull apart in layers. You can peel back a layer and smother it in the yummy goodness that accompanies it. What yummy goodness is that?

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Well, it’s this roasted garlic that comes out cooked to smithereens. Additionally, soft butter comes on the side sprinkled with pink Himalayan salt. You’ll want a little bit of this and a little bit of that added to each layer of bread.

Yachtsman’s onion rolls were so good that I don’t even know if we should talk about the steak.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

But we will. However, I want to remind you that my son has severe food allergies. He was brought a separate basket of rolls with olive oil on the side. Additionally, he could have the roasted garlic.

Our server provided him with a separate food allergy menu when it came time to order. We were told they could accommodate most of the menu items to meet his needs.

The last time we had dinner at Yachtsman was a few years ago, and we both ordered the filet mignon. Our meal was memorable, but this time I told him we had to order different menu items for the sake of this review.

I hoped he would go with the New York Strip, which our server mentioned was the house specialty. My only rule was that I was ordering the Rib Eye, and he couldn’t. But, of course, he wanted the Rib Eye then. You know how that goes.

However, he ordered the Prime Rib and a side of house-made fries. Each entree came with a choice of one accompaniment selection. Those selections were house-made fries, mashed potatoes, potato leek gratin, or haricot verts (green beans).

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

He ordered the medium-rare prime rib, which is a warm, red center. Since he has food allergies, he received a special sauce on the side. So, your presentation might be a little different than pictured.

The meat was tender and juicy, and it was a tremendous serving. It was so large he couldn’t finish it.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

For my order, I went with the Rib Eye Steak that comes topped with blue cheese shallot butter. This might be the very best steak I’ve ever enjoyed. I can’t think of another off the top of my head.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

I also ordered my steak medium rare and could cut through it with a fork. My steak sauce was divine.

I’ve already tried to make it at home but haven’t gotten it right yet. But my family enjoyed it with Christmas dinner. Thankfully, they didn’t have anything to compare it.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

My only issue with this meal was that I didn’t want any of the sides that came with the entree. If you peruse the menu a bit, you’ll notice a separate selection of steakhouse sides. These all looked good, especially the colossal asparagus.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

So I ordered a side of asparagus. My issue was that I couldn’t substitute one of the steakhouse sides for an upgraded price. I still had to order the side that came with my steak and then order this separately. So that’s a $12 order of asparagus you’re admiring.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

But it was delicious with the Meyer lemon vinaigrette. This dish felt much healthier in comparison to the large side of fries. However, I did end up nibbling on the fries since they came with my steak.

I planned to order the pineapple and coconut tart for dessert. But, unfortunately, I was so full upon finishing the steak that I completely forgot to order dessert! It wasn’t until I walked out of the restaurant that it occurred to me that I had forgotten it!

And I rarely order dessert, so I was looking forward to it beforehand. Oh well, maybe next time.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Overall, we loved our dinner at Yachtsman Steakhouse. If you enjoy steak, it’s hard to go wrong here.

Additionally, as with all fine dining, remember that a meal like this is typically slower-paced. Please remember not to have any significant plans afterward or allow enough extra time to enjoy the meal.

We were here for over an hour and a half from start to finish. Our meals usually take a bit longer given considerations for food allergies. However, we only enjoyed bread service and then entrees with no other courses. So it very well could have been longer.

If you would like to learn more about Disney’s Yacht Club, our complete list of articles is listed in our guide:

  • Disney’s Yacht Club Resort

Some recent articles include:

  • Disney’s Yacht Club Review
  • Ale and Compass Breakfast Review
  • Ale and Compass (Lunch and Dinner Review)
  • The Gift Shop At Disney’s Yacht Club

In the Comments

I hope you enjoyed this review of Yachtsman Steakhouse. We had a lovely time there. f you have any questions or thoughts, feel free to leave them in the comments below.

' src=

Hi, I'm Amber the owner of Resorts Gal . We have stayed at every single Disney Resort Hotel. Our philosophy? We believe you can have an incredible time at the resorts without ever setting foot in a theme park. We live near the parks and visit weekly and would love for you to follow along.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Disney Daily Dime

Yachtsman Steakhouse Review

If you’re looking for a more elegant and refined dinner away from the Disney World parks, you may think about eating at Yachtsman Steakhouse.  The steakhouse is located at Disney’s Yacht Club Resort, which also adjoins Disney’s Beach Club Resort.  Here in our Yachtsman Steakhouse review, we’ll tell you our thoughts on dining at this Disney World signature restaurant, covering the food and atmosphere of the restaurant.

Since Yachtsman Steakhouse is a signature location at Disney World, it does cost a bit more than your average table service meal.  That’s true whether you are paying with cash or using the Disney Dining Plan.  You’ll have to cough up two table service credits to eat here.

As with all things dining plan and Disney World, what you’re eating will determine if using the dining plan is a good value or not.  As you can see on the Yachtsman Steakhouse menu , there is a wide range of cost associated with the various entrees.  Generally, you are going to find the assortment of steaks to have the best value on the dining plan.  If you order something like chicken, then the dining plan is a poor value.  If you’re maximizing what you’re having to eat and getting steak, dessert, and a drink, then the value is much better and probably worthwhile.  Just do your own math!

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

As for the adult desserts, Carla went with a steakhouse classic (in my opinion) by ordering the Crème Brûlée.  The presentation was a bit different than the normal Crème Brûlée, as you can see.  However, the flavors were excellent.  If you’re a fan of Crème Brûlée, you can order this dessert with confidence.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Walt Disney World’s Yachtsman Steakhouse Review

' src=

I’m from Texas, and I’m not a vegetarian. Honestly, I’m as far from a vegetarian as you can get. If you’re looking for vegan restaurant recommendation, or reviews, I can’t help you. I wish I could, and I know that animals have faces and feelings, and I admit that I’m probably in the wrong – but I like my meat garnished with more meat. I think that filet, and New York Strip should be their own food group in my life. I’ve started crying over a chateaubriand before. I AM A FAN OF RED MEAT. If you, are like me, you should make your way to steak lovers heaven, also known as The Yachtsman Steakhouse.

DSC_6213

Located in The Yacht Club, this Disney Signature Restaurant just feels classy. Decked out in dark paneling, dim mood lighting, and hunter green and maroon accent colors, this is the kind of upscale restaurant you would expect to find on the East Coast. The Yachtsman Steakhouse specializes in steakhouse classics. The bread service is a little different from the normal Disney bread, as they serve traditional sourdough, and delicious onion rolls. Guys – THESE ONION ROLLS ARE BOMB. They serve them with butter and roasted garlic, and it’s probably my favorite Disney bread service. I could make a full meal out of their bread service, and several glasses of wine from Yachtsman’s delicious wine menu.

DSC_6219

We ordered the shrimp cocktail appetizer, which comes out on ice. I know it might seem hard to make a simple shrimp cocktail memorable, but this was the most delicious shrimp cocktail I’ve ever eaten. I was distinctly saddened when it was gone, and fighting my husband for the extra shrimp.

DSC_6227

The Yachtsman Steakhouse offers a huge variety of steak on their menu, with everything from filets, to strips, to a huge 32 ounce porterhouse steak intended for two people. Our advice would be this – it can be tempting to order the giant steak, just for the novelty of it, but the smaller steaks tend to be better cooked, and have more flavor. We’ve had the porterhouse, and we weren’t a huge fan of the flavor, and found the cooking throughout to be inconsistent. We ordered it medium, and some of it was rare, and some of it was well done. On this trip, we ordered a filet, and it was PERFECT. One of the best steaks I’ve had at Disney World.

DSC_6237

Share this:

  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window)

ThemeParkHipster

Yachtsman Steakhouse is Disney’s Best Kept Dining Secret, And Here’s Why (FULL REVIEW)

One of the best-kept dining secrets at Walt Disney World is Yachtsman Steakhouse at Disney’s Yacht Club Resort.

In fact, this is one of my personal favorite places to dine when I want a nice dinner at Disney. 

The beautiful steakhouse is located down a quiet corridor near the pool at the hotel and is worth trying to snag a reservation for. 

If you’re thinking about dining at one of the best restaurants at Walt Disney World keep reading to learn everything you need to know, how to snag the best tables, and of course my suggestions about what to order. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt Disney World

THIS POST MAY CONTAIN AFFILIATE LINKS. PLEASE READ MY  DISCLOSURE  FOR MORE INFO.  Which means if you click on certain links, I may receive a small commission at no additional charge to you.

What is Yachtsman Steakhouse at Walt Disney World? 

Yachtsman Steakhouse is a signature dining restaurant located at Disney’s Yacht Club Resort. The restaurant is only open for dinner and is known for its incredible steaks , sides, and desserts. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Beef Carpaccio

And believe me, you DON’T want to skip this Disney dining spot on your vacation!

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

What is the Vibe like inside Yachtsman Steakhouse?

Since the restaurant is only open for dinner the vibe is very adult. This is a great date night spot for couples , or a treat yourself type mean for solo travelers. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World NikkyJ with French 75

You’ll feel as if you’re whisked away on a nautical escapade through the great North East of America.

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World (4)

The interior is quite cozy and far away from what you’d expect at a Walt Disney World restaurant.

ORDER NOW to secure your Walt Disney World theme park ticket!  GET MY TICKETS.

How Do I get a reservation at Yachtsman Steakhouse? 

The easiest way to get a reservation for Yachtsman Steakhouse is through the My Disney Experience app. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World

You can also make reservations on the Walt Disney World website or by calling the reservation center at Walt Disney World.

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World (6)

A word of warning though, the latter of the two options is not the most efficient and phone calls to Disney have been taking upwards of two hours just to talk to someone. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Caesar Salad with Anchovies

If you do see a reservation for the restaurant you should go ahead and book it even if it’s not at your intended dining time, because it’s always easier to modify an existing reservation versus make a new one. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World (2)

If you decide you don’t want to dine at Yachtsman Steakhouse after you’ve reserved a table, you can cancel without penalty up to 24 hours before your reservation. 

Morimoto Asia in Disney Springs: Is it the BEST Sushi in Orlando?

What if I Can’t get a reservation for Yachtsman Steakhouse? 

There are a few options if you can’t get a reservation for Yachtsman Steakhouse before your trip to Walt Disney World.

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World (5)

The first is to get to the restaurant right when it opens at 5:00 p.m. and see if you can be seated.

Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Outside Crew Cup Lounge of Yachtsman’s Steakhouse with boats

Another option is to eat in the nearby lounge, Crews Cup , which is currently serving the exact same menu as Yachtsman Steakhouse. 

7 Best Lounges at Disney World To Unwind and Relax (2023)

Crews Cup Lounge 

The Crews Cup Lounge is located right next door to Yachtsman Steakhouse. Its vibe is very relaxed with tables, booths, and bar seating.

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Crew’s Cup Lounge

This lounge used to have its own unique menu , but post-pandemic the original menu has not returned and the lounge is serving the Yachtsman Steakhouse menu. 

Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Crew’s Cup Lounge Menu at Yachtsman’s Steakhouse

If you are able to snag a table inside the Crews Cup Lounge, try to get the table near the window looking into the dry-aging room at Yachtsman Steakhouse.

Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Crew Cup Lounge at Yachtsman’s Steakhouse

Through the window, you can see the steaks being expertly cut by the restaurant’s butcher for service as guests order. 

Topolino’s Terrace at Disney’s Riviera Resort is the Hardest Reservation to Get For a Reason (FULL REVIEW)

What’s on the Menu at Yachtsman Steakhouse? 

Yachtsman Steakhouse only serves dinner and everything on the menu is a la carte, meaning every item you order is a certain price. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Full menu

Meals start out with a bread basket filled with savory pull-apart onion rolls and cherry multigrain sourdough rolls.

Bread Service

The bread is served with the restaurant’s signature roasted garlic and salted butter.

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Bread service

Yes, that means you can literally smear pieces of roasted garlic and slather butter all over these delightful breads.

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Bread with roaster garlic and butter

When it comes to starters, I really enjoy the French Onion Soup , which is perfectly rich with plenty of onions, sourdough croutons, and topped with melted gruyère cheese. You definitely have to try the Beef Carpaccio as well.

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Beef Carpaccio (2

Also the famous Caesar Salad is perfect here!

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Caesar Salad

Entrees and Dessert at the Yachtsman Steakhouse

Entrees obviously mean having a steak , and no matter which one you choose it comes with a sauce or butter, and your choice of side. I always order the 14-ounce roasted prime rib with horseradish cream.

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Dirty Martini with Mashed Potatoes Steak mushrooms

Each entree comes with your choice of accompaniment, with either mashed potatoes, potato-leek gratin, or house-made French fries. I typically choose the gratin or the fries. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Menu

When dinner is done, do not leave the restaurant without trying one of the delicious desserts.

The signature dessert at the restaurant is the Yachtsman’s Chocolate Cake, which is made with dark chocolate mousse, chocolate cake, mixed berry curd, peanut butter crunch, and mousse, and serves two.

Butcher Area Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Steak display

This is one thing I love to get even if I’m dining alone so I can take the leftovers back to my Disney hotel room and munch on them the next night too. 

Why The BOATHOUSE Orlando is One of Disney’s BEST Restaurants

What to Know Before You Go to This Disney World Restaurant

You likely have a few more questions about the Yachtsman Steakhouse , so I want to be sure to answer those as well. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World (10)

Does Yachtsman Steakhouse take any discounts? 

Yes, you’ll be happy to know that Annual Passholders can get 10 percent off of their bill here. 

Yacht Club Resort Walt DIsney World

Does Yachtsman Steakhouse have a dress code? 

Yes, it’s requested that men wear khakis, slacks, or dress shirts with a collared shirt, and women should wear capri pants, skirts, dresses, or dress shorts.

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World French 75 with NikkyJ

Jeans can be worn if they are in good condition for men and women. 

Ready to plan your theme park trip? Watch the best vacation planning tips on YouTube. Get started here!

My Final Thoughts and Review of Yachtsman Steakhouse

Yachtsman Steakhouse is a lovely option for dining at Walt Disney World, whether you’re traveling alone or going out with friends, or on a date night. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World (8)

Here are a few tips to ensure your experience at Yachtsman Steakhouse is the best that it can be. 

  • Security at the front of the Yacht Club can be very strict about who they let into the parking lot at the hotel.
  • If you don’t have a confirmed dining reservation at the Yachtsman Steakhouse , your better option for dining here will be to take a ride share or take the Disney Skyliner . This is best if you’re staying at one of the resorts that the transportation service goes to and from. 
  • I f you’re at EPCOT and want a break from the park and think Yachtsman Steakhouse sounds like a nice place, you’ll want to walk to the back of the park to the International Gateway to get to the Yacht Club and to the restaurant. 

Yachtsman Steakhouse Yacht and Beach Club Resort Walt DIsney World Menu and Restaurant Entrance

Final Score and Review for Yachtsman Steakhouse at Disney

  • Ambiance:  9
  • Food:  10
  • Prices:  7.5
  • Drinks:  10
  • Service:  10

I give this restaurant a 9.3 out of 10 on the ThemeParkHipster dining scale and I know you will definitely enjoy it too!

I hope this guide helps you narrow down the places you want to eat at when visiting Walt Disney World.

Disney Yachtsman Steakhouse Review (1)

What’s your favorite place to eat at Walt Disney World? Let us know in the comments section below.

Until next time, Happy Park Hopping Hipster! 

Megan DuBois Theme Park Writer

About the Author

Megan is a theme park expert and frequent traveler to magical places. She covers all things Disney and Universal and runs marathons for fun.

She thinks you can tell a lot about someone by the name of their signature lipstick, and hers is NARS Dragon Girl.

(Original Article Date: June 6, 2022/Updated by Editor on May 18, 2024)

Share this article!

2024 Disney World Monorail Route Ultimate Guide: The Best Way to Get Around!

Rafiki’s planet watch: animal kingdom’s best kept secret at disney, leave a comment cancel reply.

the disney food blog

food IS a theme park

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Read the Latest Posts

Looking for something?

Get the dfb newsletter.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

STAY CONNECTED

EPCOT Flower & Garden Festival

Yachtsman Steakhouse

Yachtsman Steakhouse comes highly recommended by yours truly.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

I find the steaks here to be some of the best on property , and the service is often excellent.

This craftsman-inspired dining room at Disney’s Yacht Club Resort caters to all tastebuds with a variety of dishes, incredible sides, and amazing, cut-in-house steaks.

Book Online

Service: Table Service, Signature Dining

Type of Food: American, Steakhouse

Location: Disney’s Yacht Club Resort

Disney Dining Plan : Yes, 2 Table Service meal credits (Signature Dining)

Menu: Official Disney Menu

Allears.net: Yachtsman Steakhouse Dinner Menu Yachtsman Steakhouse Child’s Menu

An incredible and gourmet array of steaks, entrees, appetizers, and desserts. Sample the delicious cheese plate if you have room!

Click here to subscribe

Reviews: Spotlight: Yachtsman Steakhouse Disney Food Blog Review: Yachtsman Steakhouse Review Disney Food Blog Review: Yachtsman Steakhouse at Disney’s Yacht Club Resort Guest Review: Yachtsman Steakhouse at Disney’s Yacht Club Resort Disney Review: Porterhouse for Two at Yachtsman Steakhouse in Disney’s Yacht Club Resort Disney Food Blog Review: Yachtsman Steakhouse at the Yacht Club Resort at Walt Disney World REVIEW! It’s Wine ‘O Clock Somewhere with Disney’s Wonderful World of Wine Experience! PHOTOS: First Look at the Reopening of Yachtsman Steakhouse in Disney World Disney Food Blog Review: The Steak Restaurant You May Have Totally Overlooked in Disney World REVIEW: Is The CHEESIEST Soup in Disney World Hiding at This Forgotten Restaurant?

Important Info:

  • Have a seat by the butcher room window to see the steaks being aged right in the restaurant.
  • Catch a glimpse of the chefs working in the open kitchen as you walk to your table!
  • The Kids’ menu is especially good here, and the kids’ paint-it-yourself cookie is lots of fun!

Famous Dishes: steaks, cheese plate, creme brulee

  • Menus at Le Cellier and 20 More Disney World Restaurants Just CHANGED!
  • California Grill, San Angel Inn, and MORE Disney World Restaurants CHANGED This Week
  • Does Yachtsman Steakhouse Have a Dress Code in Disney World?
  • Only Steak Experts Eat at These 5 Disney World Restaurants
  • We’ve Eaten at Every Disney World Restaurant. These Are the Best.
  • These Secret Disney World Restaurants Are Guest Favorites…Have YOU Ever Been?
  • 19 Disney World Restaurants CHANGED Their Menus This Week
  • Yacht Club vs. Animal Kingdom Lodge Disney World Resort Guide 2023
  • We Found the Best Bread in Disney World. You’re Welcome.
  • EVERYTHING You Need To Know About Disney’s Yacht Club in 2023

CHECK OUT OUR OTHER EBOOKS

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FEED

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

TouringPlans Blog logo

Review: Dinner at the Yachtsman Steakhouse Wasn’t All Smooth Sailing

The Yachtsman Steakhouse is a Signature Dining restaurant at Disney’s Yacht Club resort. With “hand-cut, dry-aged steaks”, Disney positions the restaurant as a high-end stop for steak, and you’ll find it priced accordingly. Appetizers are $16-22, entrees $38-65, and desserts $15-20. A full three-course meal will run you about $80-95, not including drinks and gratuities. As a Signature restaurant, you’ll need to spend 2 Disney Dining Plan credits to dine at the Yachtsman.

The camera faces through the dining room to the windows; light wood on floor and slightly darker wall panels between the windows coordinate with Craftsman-style light fixtures overhead.

The restaurant’s interior leans heavily on polished wood that gives the space a warm, intimate feeling. Although the floor is bare, vertical features and ceiling joists helped to break up noise and we didn’t find that the space was loud.

The Yachtsman serves dinner only, but is open 7 days a week. You’ll often find same-day reservations or walk-up availability. And as a Signature restaurant, the Yachtsman expects guests to be in clean, neat attire – but I felt that clothing was generally more relaxed here than Signatures on the monorail loop.

Bread Course

The bread service was a mix of crusty white dinner rolls and onion rolls, accompanied by roasted garlic and butter sprinkled with sea salt. The white rolls had a nice crust, but not much flavor aside from salt. The onion rolls were the better of the pair, soft and tender with the sweet, pungent flavor of onion.

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

First Course

Caesar Salad – $16.00 Marinated White Anchovies and Croutons

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Caesar salad decorates the menus of every mid-range restaurant everywhere, but this one beats all those shlocky salads into the ground. Parmesan shavings instead of shreds, and a tangy, creamy dressing with just a hint of brine that was properly and carefully tossed to coat each leaf. The only flair was the crouton, which was a crackly crisp instead of the traditional cubes. This salad reminds you why Caesar salad is so popular that poorly executed versions became ubiquitous.

Lobster Bisque – $18.00 Lobster Biscuit / Crème Fraîche / Espelette Oil

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

I really loved the little pop of spice from the espelette oil in this bisque. The texture was perfect – creamy enough to hold up the swirls of crème fraîche and let the brightly colored oil dance on top, but still clearly a soup and not a porridge. The lobster biscuit was less of a biscuit and more of a bread cube, but provided the same overt lobster flavor that is usually served up with a few chunks of lobster meat. I liked the biscuit, but if I had a complaint about this soup that was it; no lobster meat. The biscuit just didn’t cut through the richness of the bisque in the same way.

Beef Carpaccio – $17.00 Truffle Aïoli, Parmesan, Fried Capers, Grilled Artichoke, and Smoked Sea Salt

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

I enjoyed this, but I feel it’s only fair to disclose that I adore carpaccio and pretty much always order it if it’s on the menu. So while I’m not sorry about this choice, I know that it did have a few faults. The biggest challenge of preparing carpaccio is that the contribution of the meat is fragile because the slices are so thin. It’s easy to overwhelm it if there is too much of the strongly flavored parmesan or capers, and that’s what happened here. Individual bites were tasty, although it was hard to get one that included the artichoke without using a knife, but the flavor of the beef was somewhat lost in the mix.

Butcher’s Cuts

12-oz New York Strip Steak, Prime – $59.00 Loaded Baked Potato, Peppercorn Sauce

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

My steak was perfectly cooked to temperature and nicely seasoned on the outside. It was a terrific platform upon which to try the different sauces (see below) and it tasted good without them too. I swapped the baked potato for a Yorkshire Pudding and it was outstanding. It was so outstanding that it was delicious, crisp outside, and tasty – even though it was unfortunately served cold. I very much enjoyed it, and it would almost certainly have been even better had it arrived still properly hot.

Sauce Flight – $9.00 House Steak Sauce, Béarnaise, Peppercorn, Blue Cheese, Bordelaise

Just for you, dear reader, I threw myself on the altar of sacrifice and ordered the peppercorn sauce on the side so I could try the sauce flight. OK, maybe full disclosure, peppercorn is not usually my favorite and I love to try things. Either way, I ordered my steak with the full rack of sauce.

The béarnaise was without question the best of the bunch. That isn’t just because I like béarnaise sauce, it’s because it was properly executed with the taste and texture you would expect to find in this sauce.

The bordelaise had problems. Bordelaise sauce is traditionally made with caramelized shallots and a strong stock or demi-glace that is sometimes further umami-fied with bone marrow. If you had told me this bordelaise was an onion jam, I would have believed you, and that’s not a good commentary on either the flavor or the texture.

The house steak sauce tasted much more like I would have expected the bordelaise to taste, and I’m kind of hoping that maybe our [excellent] server mislabeled the two when they were brought to the table. Except that house steak sauces don’t typically taste like onion jam either, so …

The blue cheese sauce was the kind that you will love if you love blue cheese on its own, but not if you only love the kind of blue cheese dressing that comes with wings. (That’s me, by the way, so if it’s you I’m not dissing you.) The sauce was creamy and the cheese itself was a nice choice that had enough oomph to assert itself without having the full funk of one that really needs to be the solo star.

The peppercorn was serviceable, but nothing to write home about.

22-oz Angus Bone-In Rib-Eye, Prime – $65.00 Gratin Potatoes, Red Wine Butter

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

As a plate, this was the clear winner of the two steaks we had. This steak was also perfectly cooked to temperature and with a nicely seasoned exterior; this one had more of a crust. The meat had the tender, slightly unctuous texture that you would expect from a good ribeye. And, all the accompaniments stood up. The red wine butter was tasty and brought an extra dimension to the steak, and the gratin potatoes were a lovely stack of melty gruyere goodness. Perhaps a tiny bit on the salty side, but that is often a matter of taste.

Steakhouse Sides

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Creamed Spinach – $10.50

It  is possible to make creamed spinach that doesn’t feel heavy and rich. But while this one was excellent, with the spinach flavor clearly present, it was not light. When you order it alongside a heavy, rich meal, be prepared. I really wished that I hadn’t been staying in a hotel room so I could have taken this home and eaten it the next day.

Hot Honey-Bourbon Brussels Sprouts – $12.50 Chili-candied Walnuts

Roasted Brussels sprouts, with crisp leaves and a bit of char, are all the rage these days, and it’s easy to see why a chef would want to add some hot honey and candied walnuts to make their version stand out. Alas, we couldn’t particularly taste the hot honey more than “these were dressed a bit with something a bit sweet”. The walnuts were chopped quite small and their flavor was also a bit lost as a result; I would have preferred to see them larger for more contrast.

So, these were nicely roasted and tasty, but nowhere near as special as you might think from the description. In fairness, when we mentioned this to the server she said that they had toned down the hot honey due to complaints from diners who found it too spicy for their liking.

Roasted Seasonal Mushrooms – $10.50

This was the only side that we ate all of. Buttery, woodsy, with a balance of textures from different types of mushrooms that was just right. Delicious either on the steak or off.

Smoked Paprika Fries – $10.50

It’s hard to go wrong with fries, right? These were perhaps the most disappointing dish of the night. They clearly weren’t plain frites, but I couldn’t say any paprika was in evidence – either to be seen on the fries, or tasted in the flavor.

Chocolate Cake – $17.00 Chocolate Biscuit, 65% Dark Chocolate Ganache, Chocolate Buttercream, and Raspberry

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

This dessert owes everything to the chocolate biscuit. The cake was lovely and rich, but we’ve all had great chocolate cake with great frosting. The chocolate biscuit was … think about that crunchy chocolate stuff that’s in the middle of every Carvel ice cream cake you’ve ever eaten, and then glue it together with the tart sweetness of raspberry. Amazing.

Crème Brûlée – $15.00 Luxardo Cherries, Orange Segments, Whiskey Ganache (Made with or contains alcohol product)

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Confession time: when the server described this as having the brulee topping smoked, I did a little mental side-eye. Nothing that showed on my face (at least I hope not), but I was definitely dubious. I can admit when I’m wrong. I was wrong. The cherries were beautiful, the orange segments were orange segments, the custard was a bit sweeter than your average creme brulee but it needed the oomph to hold up to the rest of the dish. But that smoked melted sugar topping!

I’m sure that I cannot describe it adequately because here’s the problem. The best description I can think of is that it had the same vaguely sweet but unfinished rough-bitter hydrocarbon flavor that you get when you set marshmallows on fire and blow them out once the coating is burnt all over. I know that thousands of us eschew the perfectly toasted marshmallow (I’m ace at that, by the way) and instead thrust them into the campfire coals because we love them burnt. But anytime you have to describe a dish using the word “hydrocarbon”, it’s a fail on the food reporting scale.

All I can tell you is that we spent 10 minutes with the server trying to figure out how to come back and get just the creme brulee without having to eat the rest of the meal first.

Wrapping Up

All in all, we found this to be a pretty disappointing meal. Although there were dishes that we enjoyed, the quality was tremendously uneven and the items we loved can (mostly) be found in other places. For the price this meal commanded, it can’t be recommended.

Here’s my advice: if it’s just a great steak that you’re looking for, a superior plate can be had at the Boathouse in Disney Springs or Toledo at Coronado Springs Resort. If you’re looking for a stellar meal with steak on the menu try Citricos, which has an outstanding strip steak — better than what was served here.

If you’re staying at the Yacht or Beach Club and you’re looking for a light meal, wander over to the Yachtsman and see if they have a table. (You can probably check in advance using the Walk-Up Waitlist ). Treat yourself to a great Caesar Salad and maybe a bowl of lobster bisque, and then skip straight to dessert. You know what you need to order there, right? It’s the amazing creme brulee.

Have you been to the Yachtsman Steakhouse? What did you think of your meal? Let us know in the comments!

You May Also Like...

yachtsman steakhouse reviews

Cape May Cafe is a seaside-inspired buffet located just off the lobby of Disney's Beach Club Resort. Open for both breakfast…

Steakhouse 71 Lunch Review - entrance to Steakhouse 71

Know Before You Go Steakhouse 71 is a restaurant on the 1st floor of Disney's Contemporary Resort. The cuisine is American,…

  • Spring and Summer 2024 Room Discounts at Disneyland Resort
  • Disney in a Minute: What Does “E-Ticket” Mean?

Jennifer Heymont

Jennifer has a background in math and biology, so she ended up in Data Science where she gets to do both. She lives just north of Boston with her husband, kids, and assorted animal members of the family. Although it took three visits for the Disney bug to "take", she now really wishes she lived a lot closer to the Parks.

' src=

6 thoughts on “ Review: Dinner at the Yachtsman Steakhouse Wasn’t All Smooth Sailing ”

We have not been there in the last five years but were regulars in the past. Shall I assume that the menu and the prep have diminished?

I can’t say what it was like 5 years ago (prior to this visit we ate there once, and it was farther in the past than that). But the word on the street from others is that yes, it has diminished. Even if it has not, I can honestly say based on our experience recently that there are much better places to get a steak at Disney World.

Normally I enjoy these reviews but this feels overly harsh when comparing the headline & wrap-up to the actual dish reviews. I was expecting an absolute trainwreck (shipwreck?) but it read as a lot of personal preferences or minor flaws – cold Yorkshire pudding aside which is an insult I can’t let pass.

Maybe it’s more about the cost vs quality?

I hear what you’re saying about it not seeming to add up and I can totally see where you’re coming from as a reader. But as a reviewer, I’d say that’s exactly the reason that there is a headline and a wrap-up. There were 13 dishes reviewed here (bread service, 3 appetizers, 2 steaks, sauce flight, 4 sides, 2 desserts). Of those plates, 1 appetizer, 1 steak plate, the sauce flight, 2 of the 4 sides had errors in composition or execution. That’s a 38% miss rate for a restaurant that – even on the Disney scale – is expensive at a base price of $80-95 for 3 courses.

The problem is: just because an error doesn’t make food taste bad doesn’t mean that dish isn’t a miss. Billing a dish as “smoked paprika fries” is an elevation that you expect from a fine dining restaurant, and it affects a diner’s decision to order something that feels as though it is unique. When what lands on the table is basically plain fries, it doesn’t matter that they’re perfectly good regular fries. Because if the diner knew that when ordering, they might have chosen to try something they didn’t feel they could get elsewhere.

Similarly, that I enjoyed the carpaccio doesn’t mean that my criticism of it was personal preference (which I do try to note when it applies). The fact is, you are not supposed to need a knife to get a complete bite of a carpaccio dish. And, you are supposed to be able to distinctly and clearly taste the beef. I don’t know if you watch Beat Bobby Flay, but there is a repeated theme where he makes something that the judges say “I don’t know if I’d call this a __________, but it was very tasty”. Everyone has their own opinion about whether not being a _____________ should be disqualifying and if it’s a travesty when he wins, but it’s also a TV show. In everyday restaurant eating, diners want to have some confidence that they dish that appears in front of them will match their expectations based on the dish name and description.

And yes, errors like these are more likely to be forgiven in a restaurant that doesn’t bill itself as being high caliber. One of the things that comes with billing as a fine dining establishment is an assumption about how well dishes match their menu descriptions or the standards of the dish. If these problems had occurred at, say, the Grand Floridian Cafe with its much lower price tag, I would still have called them out but probably not had such a harsh take on the overall experience. But also, a restaurant in the weight class of the Grand Floridian Cafe is not as likely to be the one that a vacationing family with a limited budget has chosen as their “big splurge dinner”.

Thanks for taking the time to explain. Never been to this restaurant so not trying to defend it in any way, was just genuinely a bit confused while reading!

No worries – as I said, I see why it could be confusing as a reader. So thanks for asking and giving me a chance to elaborate for anyone else who might be similarly mystified. 🙂

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

  • Vacation Rentals
  • Restaurants
  • Things to do
  • Moscow Tourism
  • Moscow Hotels
  • Moscow Bed and Breakfast
  • Moscow Vacation Rentals
  • Flights to Moscow
  • Moscow Restaurants
  • Things to Do in Moscow
  • Moscow Travel Forum
  • Moscow Photos
  • All Moscow Hotels
  • Moscow Hotel Deals
  • Moscow Motels
  • Moscow Hostels
  • Moscow Campgrounds
  • Moscow Business Hotels
  • Moscow Spa Resorts
  • Moscow Family Hotels
  • Moscow Luxury Hotels
  • Romantic Hotels in Moscow
  • Moscow Green Hotels
  • Moscow Ski-In / Ski-Out Hotels
  • Moscow Resorts
  • 5-stars Hotels in Moscow
  • 4-stars Hotels in Moscow
  • 3-stars Hotels in Moscow
  • Novotel Hotels in Moscow
  • Crowne Plaza Hotels in Moscow
  • Rotana Hotels in Moscow
  • Accor Hotels in Moscow
  • InterContinental (IHG) Hotels in Moscow
  • Radisson Hotels in Moscow
  • Hilton Hotels in Moscow
  • Holiday Inns in Moscow
  • ibis Hotels in Moscow
  • Radisson Blu Hotels in Moscow
  • Hampton by Hilton Hotels in Moscow
  • AZIMUT Hotels in Moscow
  • Moscow Hotels with Pools
  • Pet Friendly Hotels in Moscow
  • Moscow Hotels with Free Parking
  • 3rd Transport Ring (TTK) Hotels
  • District Central (TsAO) Hotels
  • Garden Ring Hotels
  • Boulevard Ring Hotels
  • Tverskoy Hotels
  • Red Square & Kitay-gorod Hotels
  • Zamoskvorechye Hotels
  • Meshchanskiy Hotels
  • Presnensky Hotels
  • District Eastern (VAO) Hotels
  • Discount Hotels in Moscow
  • Boutique Hotels in Moscow
  • Heritage Hotels in Moscow
  • Hotels with Nightclubs in Moscow
  • Moscow Downtown Hotels
  • Luxury Family Hotels in Moscow
  • Cheap Moscow Bed and Breakfast
  • Hotels With Entertainment in Moscow
  • Hotels With Babysitting in Moscow
  • Honeymoon Hotels in Moscow
  • Hotels near Red Square
  • Hotels near Moscow Metro
  • Hotels near Saint Basil's Cathedral
  • Hotels near Moscow Kremlin
  • Hotels near High-Speed Train Sapsan
  • Hotels near GUM
  • Hotels near State Tretyakov Gallery
  • Hotels near Tsaritsyno Museum-Reserve
  • Hotels near Armoury Chamber
  • Hotels near Bolshoi Theatre
  • Hotels near Kremlin Walls and Towers
  • Hotels near Gorky Central Park of Culture and Leisure
  • Hotels near Kolomenskoye Historical and Architectural Museum and Reserve
  • Hotels near PANORAMA360
  • Hotels near (ZIA) Zhukovsky International Airport
  • Hotels near (VKO) Vnukovo Airport
  • Hotels near (DME) Domodedovo Airport
  • Grand Hyatt Baha Mar
  • Hyatt Ziva Cap Cana
  • Sunburst Inn
  • Giraffe Manor
  • Mohonk Mountain House
  • Horseshoe Las Vegas
  • Westgate Las Vegas Resort & Casino
  • Secrets Akumal Riviera Maya
  • Riolavitas Resort & Spa
  • Aruba Ocean Villas
  • Beaches Turks & Caicos
  • Disney's All-Star Movies Resort
  • Disney's Coronado Springs Resort
  • Park MGM Las Vegas
  • Hilton Grand Vacations Club on the Las Vegas Strip
  • Popular All-Inclusive Resorts
  • Popular Beach Resorts
  • Popular Family Resorts
  • Popular All-Inclusive Hotels
  • Popular Hotels With Waterparks
  • Popular Honeymoon Resorts
  • Popular Luxury Resorts
  • Popular All-Inclusive Family Resorts
  • Popular Golf Resorts
  • Popular Spa Resorts
  • Popular Cheap Resorts
  • All Moscow Restaurants
  • Restaurants near Restaurant-Yacht Lastochka
  • Cafés in Moscow
  • Chinese Restaurants with Outdoor Seating in Moscow
  • Fast Food Restaurants in Moscow
  • French Restaurants with Outdoor Seating in Moscow
  • Italian Restaurants in Moscow
  • Japanese Restaurants in Moscow
  • Mediterranean Restaurants in Moscow
  • Pizza in Moscow
  • Russian Restaurants in Moscow
  • Seafood Restaurants in Moscow
  • Steakhouses for Large Groups in Moscow
  • Vegan Restaurants in Moscow
  • Vegetarian Restaurants in Moscow
  • Best Ice Cream in Moscow
  • Best Ceviche in Moscow
  • Best Ribs in Moscow
  • Best Club Sandwich in Moscow
  • Best Dumplings in Moscow
  • Best Oyster in Moscow
  • Best Wings in Moscow
  • Best Prosciutto in Moscow
  • Best Tiramisu in Moscow
  • Best Cupcakes in Moscow
  • Best Waffles in Moscow
  • Best Crab Legs in Moscow
  • Best Clams in Moscow
  • Best Shawarma in Moscow
  • Best Mussels in Moscow
  • Breakfast Restaurants in Moscow
  • Lunch Restaurants in Moscow
  • Dinner Restaurants in Moscow
  • Bakeries in Moscow
  • Buffet Restaurants in Moscow
  • Coffee & Tea in Moscow
  • Desserts in Moscow
  • Food Delivery Restaurants in Moscow
  • Kid Friendly Restaurants in Moscow
  • Late Night Restaurants in Moscow
  • Restaurants for Special Occasions in Moscow
  • Restaurants with Outdoor Seating in Moscow
  • Romantic Restaurants in Moscow
  • Arbat Restaurants
  • Basmanny Restaurants
  • Coffee & Tea in Tverskaya
  • Dumplings in Red Square & Kitay-gorod
  • Khamovniki Restaurants
  • Maryina Roshcha (Jewish Quarter) Restaurants
  • Mediterranean Restaurants for Large Groups in Presnensky
  • Patriarch Ponds Restaurants
  • Presnensky Restaurants
  • Private Dining Restaurants in Zamoskvorechye
  • Red Square & Kitay-gorod Restaurants
  • Seafood Restaurants in Arbat
  • Tverskaya Restaurants
  • Yakimanka Restaurants
  • Zamoskvorechye Restaurants
  • GreenLeaders
  • Things to Do
  • Travel Stories
  • Rental Cars
  • Add a Place
  • Travel Forum
  • Travelers' Choice
  • Help Center
  • Europe    
  • Russia    
  • Central Russia    
  • Moscow    
  • Moscow Restaurants    

Restaurant-Yacht Lastochka

Ratings and reviews, location and contact.

Truly an amazing wining and dining experience in atmosphere of relaxation and luxury. Excellent view of Moskva river, impeccable service. We’ve tried seviche, tataki, gazpacho with crab, risotto with scallops and ravioli with langoustine. Everything was just unbelievably delicious. Desert was wonderful as well. We’ve... had a mango and passion fruit mousse. All these excellent dishes were lavishly watered with great champagne and wines, lots of prominent examples on the list. Heavily recommend visiting this place. More

The benefit of cruising the Moscow river without moving from the embarkment place. That is what Lastochka is about. Add then nice atmosphere, good food and high level service. I recommend it.

The restaurant is a great ambience, the food is delicious and the service is good The waiter Nadya is very nice and provides the service professionally

I loved this place! Service and food were great! You are on a huge boat with a great view. I recommend the Pinot Grigio, Peking duck, pasta, asparagus salad, salad with goat cheese and beets was to die for! And Napoleon was amazing! I will... definitely be back! More

RESTAURANT-YACHT LASTOCHKA, Moscow - District Central (TsAO) - Restaurant Reviews, Photos & Phone Number - Tripadvisor

  • Service: 4.5
  • Atmosphere: 4.5
  • Share full article

A man in a paisley button-up shirt stands outside, with a large R.V. vehicle visible behind him and a few white flowers in close-up in front of him.

He Sang ‘What a Fool Believes.’ But Michael McDonald Is in on the Joke.

The singer and songwriter with a silky-smooth voice has written a memoir with Paul Reiser that recounts his story of pain and redemption with dashes of humor.

Michael McDonald’s new memoir is titled “What a Fool Believes,” after the Grammy-winning hit he wrote in 1978 with Kenny Loggins. Credit... Ariel Fisher for The New York Times

Supported by

Alexandra Jacobs

By Alexandra Jacobs

Reporting from Santa Barbara, Calif.

  • Published May 9, 2024 Updated May 16, 2024

The voice of Michael McDonald has been compared to velvet , silk and sandpaper , melted chocolate and last year, by a besotted 11-year-old girl, an angel . He has harmonized with the best in the business. But his latest duet might cause even the most Botoxed foreheads of Hollywood to furrow.

Listen to this article with reporter commentary

“How you like us so far?” joked Paul Reiser, the actor and comedian, from one corner of a squishy sofa in McDonald’s Santa Barbara, Calif., aerie on a recent Tuesday morning. He was there to talk about the singer’s memoir, which they wrote together and will be published by Dey Street Books on May 21.

In the other corner, emanating the equanimity that’s as beloved as his baritone, was the man whose 50-plus-year career has included backup vocals for Steely Dan, Elton John , El DeBarge , Toto , Bonnie Raitt and on and on — backup so extensive and distinctive it’s inspired playlists on Apple Music and Spotify . He was wearing a paisley-patterned shirt, black trousers and, as one might expect of an angel who must tread this cursed Earth, puffy Hoka sneakers .

McDonald, 72, has also spent decades in the spotlight, albeit sidlingly, often with his famous blue eyes shut . (“Singing is such an intimate act,” he explains in the book, “and like kissing, it does no real good to see what the other person is doing.”) He led the Doobie Brothers in various iterations with his gospel-inflected keyboard style; released nine solo studio albums traversing multiple genres and continues to make live appearances at venues from Coachella to the Carlyle .

A man in a black shirt and dark pants stands a few feet behind a man in a paisley shirt with a white beard, both outside in a garden near a house with an angled roof.

The book is titled “What a Fool Believes,” after the Grammy-winning hit McDonald wrote in 1978 with Kenny Loggins, though with some hesitation. “I thought, ‘Well, that’s just too obvious,’” he said. “I wanted it to be something clever and mind-provoking, and I couldn’t really think of anything because, you know, I have a problem provoking my own mind.”

He was convinced by Reiser, who among many other projects wrote the best-selling books “Couplehood” and “Babyhood” in the 1990s, and a follow-up, “Familyhood,” in 2011.

“I mean, how lucky am I?” McDonald said.

“Awwww,” Reiser said. But seriously: “He’s very introspective, which you don’t see at first and then you go, ‘Oh, this guy is deeper than you think.’” A beat. “Not that I thought you were shallow!”

As if in a marathon therapy session, they plunged together back to the past. McDonald grew up Irish Catholic, bracketed by two sisters in a suburb of St. Louis. His father was a streetcar driver and ex-Marine, a teetotaler with an eye for the ladies and a beautiful singing voice. His mother worked in a trading stamps store and had a weakness for pep pills. The marriage didn’t last.

He had an Aunt Mame with a Victrola from which, at age 5, he learned to imitate Mario Lanza warbling “ Love is a Many-Splendored Thing ”; an Aunt Bitsy who introduced him to Rodgers and Hammerstein; and an Aunt Ann Catherine whose record collection included, revelatorily, Ray Charles. Burt Bacharach was a big influence, too. Beatles-wise, he gravitated more toward McCartney than Lennon.

“I always related to him,” McDonald said, “because I could sense from him that he heard a lot of the same music I heard — that kind of barroom, Tin Pan Alley chord progression.”

In one devastating passage, McDonald writes of getting his girlfriend pregnant in eighth grade and biking over to confront her parents, who insisted, along with his own, that she give the baby up for adoption. Too young to sort through this emotional wreckage, he steered away. “Disappearing became my MO,” he writes. “Distancing myself from whatever it was that might require accountability.”

He dropped out of high school and joined a series of colorful-sounding bands — the Majestics, the Sheratons, the Delrays, the Guild, the Blue. Old ballrooms; natty threads. Beer and marijuana became staples, and later, after he moved to Los Angeles and began breaking into the big time, cocaine.

Referred to Steely Dan by the drummer Jeff Porcaro in 1973, he “came to rehearsal a few days later and knocked everyone out,” Donald Fagen, the band’s surviving founder, wrote in an email. “There was a serious discussion about whether he should replace me as the lead singer, which would have been my personal preference. But, for some dumb reason, I was voted down. I didn’t insist, and I’ve regretted it ever since. I mean, here’s this monster singer and musician, and he’s also really funny and a sweetheart of a guy. What’s not to like?”

Patti LaBelle called about recording “ On My Own ” (1986) with McDonald, after a solo version went sour. “I said, ‘The person I would love to sing it with is quiet, beautiful Michael,’” she remembered. Recently they crooned it together on a jazz cruise on the Norwegian Pearl where, she said, he confessed nerves beforehand; when he emerged onstage, the crowd went bananas. “He’s one of a kind. He comes out whispering and then — all this power. It’s like he doesn’t even open his mouth, he’s just so laid back.”

Indeed, so constitutionally low-key is McDonald that Loggins, with whom he also composed “ This is It ” and “ I Gotta Try, ” and who released his own memoir, “ Still Alright ,” in 2022, didn’t even know his old collaborator is about to join him on the bookshelves.

On the phone, Loggins remembered the first time he heard McDonald in the Doobies’ “ Livin’ on the Fault Line .” “I just felt like, ‘Oh, this is going to be a major American voice,’” he said. “He kind of goes into a trance when we write, and if I say ‘play it again,’ he won’t remember, so I have to record all the time. We have completely different styles vocally, but blend really well. It’s not logical.”

In 2005, the duo, along with Hall and Oates, Christopher Cross, Toto, Steve Perry and others, were affectionately spoofed in J.D. Ryznar’s web series, “ Yacht Rock .” A strain of the much-maligned catchall “adult contemporary” category was suddenly rebranded as “smooth music”: gleaming with high production values and a general mellifluence; the polar opposite of punk. McDonald was portrayed as the genre’s earnest common denominator: its anchor, its intergenerational secret sauce, who stumbles out of fashion and then rises again when “ I Keep Forgettin ’” is sampled by Warren G in 1994.

McDonald compared the yacht-rock phenomenon to oldies radio. “Even though I was a little ambivalent about both, at first, they turned out to be the two best things that ever happened to us from the ’70s,” he said, “because we kept getting airplay.”

This wasn’t his first time as a figure of comedy. In 1981, in an SCTV sketch, Rick Moranis portrayed McDonald driving intently down a highway in a convertible to clap on headphones and sing bits of backup for Cross’s “Ride Like the Wind” before rushing off to his next gig. McDonald contributed a song to the 1999 “South Park” movie and sang at a fictional “30 Rock” benefit . In “The 40-Year-Old Virgin” (2005), an electronics-store manager played by Jane Lynch is excoriated by an employee for broadcasting a McDonald concert video ad nauseam. (“If I have to hear ‘ Yah Mo B There ’ one more time I’m going to yah mo burn this place to the ground!”) And in 2013 Jimmy Fallon and Justin Timberlake donned silver McDonald wigs to sing “ Row, Row, Row Your Boat ” with him.

We have his current writing partner to thank, or blame, for the chapter title “Doobie or Not Doobie, That Is the Question.” Reiser, an accomplished musician himself who can sit down at the Yamaha and spontaneously ripple off a Rachmaninoff concerto, first encountered McDonald performing during an event at a neighbor’s house. “And in a surge of moxie, I went, ‘I live literally next door, and I got a music studio with two pianos that I put in just in case this ever happened,’” Reiser recalled. “Would you like to come over?’”

A jam session ensued. A friendship developed. Then the pandemic descended. McDonald thought that during lockdown he might apply himself with renewed vigor to his painting hobby . Reiser had another idea. “He’s the only reason the book exists, as far as I know,” McDonald said. “Putting one foot in front of the other was never my strong suit, on my own power. By myself, I become like a blob.”

McDonald’s wife, the singer Amy Holland, wandered briefly into their living room, which is large, cozy and barnlike, with plenty of blankets and candles and a banjo mounted on the wall bearing the visage of her mother, Verna Sherrill Boersma, who did a hillbilly routine as Esmereldy in the 1940s and resembled …. was it Bette Davis? “Celeste Holm,” McDonald said.

He and Holland were married in 1983, with David Pack, the lead singer of Ambrosia performing “Biggest Part of Me” at the reception. They have two adult children, a submissive golden retriever, and a possessive Chihuahua who sleeps in between the couple.

One of their previous pooches cringed at his singing, McDonald noted, and would try to pry his master’s hands off the piano keys every time he played.

“Everyone’s a critic,” Reiser said.

Working with McDonald, he said, was often just a process of having him slow down and fill out anecdotes that, to him, seemed like no big deal — Steely Dan partying in the penthouse of a London hotel, for one. “I’m going, ‘That’s like a Fellini movie!’” One chapter is devoted to an extended bender with the band’s co-founder, Walter Becker , who died in 2017; another features an unintentional acid trip. ( David Gest also makes an appearance.)

“I remember looking to the guys who seem to manage it well — guys who did a little of this and did a little of that but didn’t have a problem like I suspect that I already did,” McDonald said. “Their whole thing was ‘You just got to manage it — you can’t overdo it, man.’” He paused. “And every one of those guys, to a man, is gone.”

Sober since the mid-80s — he said his current vices are “food and sloth” — McDonald is not only still here, but discreetly ubiquitous.

Forget about velvet and silk: The more you read and think and listen, the more his voice seems like a connecting thread running through America’s popular-music tapestry that, if pulled, might unravel the whole thing — or at least, leave a significant, unmendable hole.

And yet, he said, “to this day I keep expecting the doors to fly open and the impostor police to come and grab me and take me out.”

Read by Alexandra Jacobs

Audio produced by Jack D’Isidoro .

Alexandra Jacobs is a Times book critic and occasional features writer. She joined The Times in 2010. More about Alexandra Jacobs

Find the Right Soundtrack for You

Trying to expand your musical horizons take a listen to something new..

Just how big is Taylor Swift ?

Billie Eilish  dares to write (twisted) love songs. Her new LP is a Critic’s Pick.

Listen to a conversation about Steve Albini’s legacy on Popcast .

Meet Carlos Niño , the spiritual force behind L.A.’s eclectic music scene.

Hear 11 of the week’s most notable new songs on the Playlist .

Advertisement

IMAGES

  1. Yachtsman Steakhouse Dining Review • WDW Vacation Tips

    yachtsman steakhouse reviews

  2. Yachtsman Steakhouse Review: Disney World's Most Magnificent Meats

    yachtsman steakhouse reviews

  3. Yachtsman Steakhouse Review

    yachtsman steakhouse reviews

  4. Disney's Yachtsman Steakhouse Review

    yachtsman steakhouse reviews

  5. Yachtsman Steakhouse Review: Disney World's Most Magnificent Meats

    yachtsman steakhouse reviews

  6. Yachtsman Steakhouse Full Review

    yachtsman steakhouse reviews

VIDEO

  1. Yachtsman Steakhouse Disney's Yacht Ckub Resort #disneyworld #disneydining #yachtsmanteakhouse

  2. Disney's Yacht Club Resort Breakfast At Yachtsman Steakhouse 2024

  3. A Chicago Steak or a Disney World Steak? A Chicago Cut Steakhouse Review!

  4. Sailfish 226DC The Fisherman Magazine Review

  5. hyde park steakhouse review

  6. Vlog #12

COMMENTS

  1. YACHTSMAN STEAKHOUSE

    376 reviews and 963 photos of YACHTSMAN STEAKHOUSE "I've been to the Yachtsman Steakhouse twice now and both experiences were good though a bit different. The first time I had dinner here, everything was top notch! We ordered a little bit of everything on the menu. The staff was friendly and the service was top notch. The second time we went to eat here, the service was fine.

  2. Yachtsman Steakhouse Review: Disney World's Most Magnificent Meats?

    For the last decade, Yachtsman Steakhouse has been a staple of our Top 10 Table Service Restaurants at Walt Disney World.We've praised it as a carnivore's paradise for glorious cuts of meat and the most approachable Signature Dining for guests who want something straightforward, delicious, and unfussy.. Yachtsman Steakhouse once ranked inside the top 5 on that list, and although it never ...

  3. You Won't Be Mad at Yachtsman Steakhouse in Disney World … Probably

    Atmosphere. We'll start with a look at the general atmosphere of this spot. As we mentioned above, Yachtsman is located at the Yacht Club. It is an upscale steakhouse, but isn't a spot that feels overly formal or stuffy. You'll head to the boat-shaped spot to check-in (or you can check-in online through the My Disney Experience app).

  4. Yachtsman Steakhouse Review

    Yachtsman Steakhouse looks nice with its masculine woods and understated dining room, and the highlight is when you first walk in and see a butcher room with meats aging and, when we were there, a butcher in there actually making his cuts! However, there are also a few random accents that make the restaurant feel as if it's stuck in the mid ...

  5. YACHTSMAN STEAKHOUSE, Orlando

    Yachtsman Steakhouse. Claimed. Review. Share. 1,548 reviews #201 of 2,077 Restaurants in Orlando $$$$ American Steakhouse Gluten Free Options. 1700 Epcot Resorts Boulevard Disney's Yacht Club Resort, Orlando, FL 32830 +1 407-939-5277 Website Menu. Open now : 5:00 PM - 9:30 PM. Improve this listing.

  6. Review: Yachtsman Steakhouse at the Yacht Club Resort at Walt Disney

    Yachtsman Steakhouse has a solid reputation as a place to get a reliable steak with tasty sides (and awesome pull-apart onion bread…). Located in the subtly elegant Yacht Club, with its nostalgic lobby smell and clean, nautical lines, Yachtsman is a convenient out-of-park place to grab a meal, being proximal to both Epcot and Hollywood Studios.

  7. REVIEW: Yachtsman Steakhouse Reopens With Delicious Prime Cuts, Fresh

    REVIEW: Yachtsman Steakhouse Reopens With Delicious Prime Cuts, Fresh Seafood, and More at Disney's Yacht Club Resort. As we reported earlier, Yachtsman Steakhouse has reopened at Disney's Yacht Club Resort. Guests can savor premium steaks, fresh seafood, and more at this New England-style steakhouse. We stopped by for dinner; let's see ...

  8. Yachtsman Steakhouse Full Review

    Try it, you won't be disappointed! Yachtsman Steakhouse is a Dinner only restaurant and is open from roughly 5:00pm - 9:30pm Daily . The Disney Dining Plan is also accepted, it is a 2 Disney Dining Credit Signature Restaurant. Reservations can be made via the Disney World website or by calling (407) WDW-DINE.

  9. YACHTSMAN STEAKHOUSE, Orlando

    Review. Save. Share. 1,548 reviews. #201 of 2,070 Restaurants in Orlando$$$$, American, Steakhouse, Gluten Free Options. 1700 Epcot Resorts Boulevard Disney's Yacht Club Resort, Orlando, FL 32830. +1 407-939-5277 + Add website. Menu. Closed now See all hours.

  10. A Favorable Review of Yachtsman Steakhouse

    Yachtsman Steakhouse is the signature dining location at Disney's Yacht Club Resort. Those looking to enjoy a meal with quality steaks during their Disney World vacation will want to consider this establishment. ... In this review of Yachtsman Steakhouse, we'll look at our latest dining experience along with a few thoughts for planning a ...

  11. Yachtsman Steakhouse Review

    Everything you need to know about Yachtsman Steakhouse, from our travel experts. Walt Disney World Orlando Travel Guide Walt Disney World Orlando Things To Do

  12. YACHTSMAN STEAKHOUSE

    368 reviews and 924 photos of Yachtsman Steakhouse "I've been to the Yachtsman Steakhouse twice now and both experiences were good though a bit different. The first time I had dinner here, everything was top notch! We ordered a little bit of everything on the menu. The staff was friendly and the service was top notch. The second time we went to eat here, the service was fine.

  13. Yachtsman Steakhouse Review

    Yachtsman Steakhouse is a table-service restaurant in Walt Disney World's Yacht Club Resort. Termed as a signature restaurant, Yachtsman Steakhouse would require two credits on the Disney Dining Plan (when applicable) and has higher prices than the usual sit down spot at WDW although they do offer Annual Pass and DVC discounts.

  14. Yachtsman Steakhouse Review

    Yachtsman Steakhouse does accept Tables in Wonderland.. We actually used it for this Yachtsman Steakhouse review! We love saving 20%. One thing unique to Yachtsman Steakhouse (and most other signature dining restaurants) is the presence of a dress code.

  15. Walt Disney World's Yachtsman Steakhouse Review

    The Yachtsman Steakhouse offers a huge variety of steak on their menu, with everything from filets, to strips, to a huge 32 ounce porterhouse steak intended for two people. Our advice would be this - it can be tempting to order the giant steak, just for the novelty of it, but the smaller steaks tend to be better cooked, and have more flavor.

  16. YACHTSMAN STEAKHOUSE

    376 reviews and 963 photos of YACHTSMAN STEAKHOUSE "I've been to the Yachtsman Steakhouse twice now and both experiences were good though a bit different. The first time I had dinner here, everything was top notch! We ordered a little bit of everything on the menu. The staff was friendly and the service was top notch. The second time we went to eat here, the service was fine.

  17. Yachtsman Steakhouse is Disney's Best Kept Dining Secret, And Here's

    Final Score and Review for Yachtsman Steakhouse at Disney. Ambiance: 9; Food: 10; Prices: 7.5; Drinks: 10; Service: 10; I give this restaurant a 9.3 out of 10 on the ThemeParkHipster dining scale and I know you will definitely enjoy it too! I hope this guide helps you narrow down the places you want to eat at when visiting Walt Disney World.

  18. Yachtsman Steakhouse

    Yachtsman Steakhouse. I find the steaks here to be some of the best on property, and the service is often excellent. This craftsman-inspired dining room at Disney's Yacht Club Resort caters to all tastebuds with a variety of dishes, incredible sides, and amazing, cut-in-house steaks. Book Online. Service: Table Service, Signature Dining.

  19. Yachtsman Steakhouse / An Honest Review

    For our anniversary of being together 16 years we decided to try Yachtsman Steakhouse at Disney's Yacht Club Resort. Spoiler alert, we probably would not go ...

  20. Review: Dinner at the Yachtsman Steakhouse Wasn't All Smooth Sailing

    The Yachtsman Steakhouse is a Signature Dining restaurant at Disney's Yacht Club resort. With "hand-cut, dry-aged steaks", Disney positions the restaurant as a high-end stop for steak, and you'll find it priced accordingly. Appetizers are $16-22, entrees $38-65, and desserts $15-20. A full three-course meal will run you about $80-95 ...

  21. YACHTSMAN STEAKHOUSE

    Disney's Yacht Club Resort. 1700 Epcot Resorts Blvd. Orlando, FL 32830. Disney World, Horizons West / West Orlando. Get directions. Mon. 5:00 PM - 9:30 PM. Tue. 5:00 PM - 9:30 PM.

  22. RESTAURANT-YACHT LASTOCHKA, Moscow

    Restaurant-Yacht Lastochka, Moscow: See 119 unbiased reviews of Restaurant-Yacht Lastochka, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #424 of 15,530 restaurants in Moscow.

  23. Russia Starts Tactical Nuclear Drills, in a Warning to Ukraine's Allies

    May 21, 2024 Updated 3:55 p.m. ET. Russia sent a pointed reminder on Tuesday that it could use battlefield nuclear weapons in Ukraine, releasing video of its forces beginning exercises to practice ...

  24. He Sang 'What a Fool Believes.' But Michael McDonald Is in on the Joke

    Michael McDonald's new memoir is titled "What a Fool Believes," after the Grammy-winning hit he wrote in 1978 with Kenny Loggins. Ariel Fisher for The New York Times. The voice of Michael ...